Auto Icon

Auto

We browse through a wide variety of coverages and find the right one for you.
Get a Quote
Home Icon

Home

We browse through a wide variety of coverages and find the right one for you.
Get a Quote
Business Icon

Business

We browse through a wide variety of coverages and find the right one for you.
Get a Quote
Life Icon

Life

We browse through a wide variety of coverages and find the right one for you.
Get a Quote
Workers Compensation Icon

Workers Compensation

We browse through a wide variety of coverages and find the right one for you.
Get a Quote
Recreational Vehicle Icon

Recreational Vehicle

We browse through a wide variety of coverages and find the right one for you.
Get a Quote

Testimonials

Cynthia S.

The McIlrath Insurance Agency focuses on customer service and satisfaction, I have used them on both a personal level as well as a business one and everyone there has been professional, knowledgeable and amazing to work with!

 

David W.

I have been working with Mcllrath for about 2 years. The staff have been very helpful. The services are excellent. The agency has plenty of products to meet my needs and the rates are great

Dave I.

I bounced around from agent to agent for years. I finally chose Pam and McIlrath Insurance what seems like decades ago. I won’t switch again. Always the most reasonable rates for both home and auto and fantastic customer service. Very professional and highly responsive.

Jill P

I couldn’t be happier with my experience with McIlrath Insurance Agency. I didn’t realize that they also were able to get me the best Medicare Advantage Plan. Those plans are so confusing and overwhelming, and Mac took the time to explain all the details and made it crystal clear!!!!

Positive
Responsiveness, Quality, Professionalism, Value

Wayne

Pamela and Karen at Mcllrath Insurance Agency were wonderful to work with, timely and efficient in their follow up and I couldn’t be happier that they saved me almost 40% on my homeowners insurance! I’ll be working with them moving forward for all my insurance needs.

Positive
Responsiveness, Quality, Professionalism, Value

Sarah M

I called McIlrath insurance agency randomly after finding them online. That was 5 years ago. We now have bought our auto, home, rental property insurance, umbrella liability policy, and life insurance through their company. Pamela has been tremendous to work with – fast response time, willingness to find carriers with good rates, and always available to tweak the policies as we buy, sell, and invest in real estate. I switched from a big name insurance brokerage and have saved hundreds on each policy. Highly highly recommend.

Kelly Youkers

All of the staff at McIlrath are so helpful!! We work most with Pamela for our home and auto policies and also with Candy for my husband’s business insurance. They work hard to ensure we are getting the best rates and coverage possible and are always available if we have any questions. Excellent customer service!

Paul McGonagle

I appreciate all the expertise of McIlrath Insurance Agency. We moved into PA and the transition process for home and auto is significant. McIlrath was professional and cordial and a real pleasure to work with. Their quotes are the best in the area.
We are grateful for all they did for us.

Lisa Burkart-Chalmers

Pamela is the best. When I call or email her a question- she is quick to respond. Always professional and cares about her clients.

Ben Lodico

I’ve utilized McIlrath insurance for many different lines of coverage, and love the service, expertise, value and communication received! EXCELLENT!

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

©2026. All rights reserved. | Powered by Zywave Websites